Present Day through 1733

• Jill Cowie, 2017-present
• J. Mark Worth (interim), 2015-2017
• Wendy L. Bell, 2001-2015
• Paul L’Herrou (interim), 1999-2001
• Deborah R. Mero, 1996-1999
• Will Saunders (interim), 1995-1996
• George Briggs (interim), 1994-1995
• Malcolm R. Sutherland, Jr., 1975-1994
• David Dalrymple, 1973-1975
• Carl D. Bretz, 1964-1972
• Deane Starr, 1963-1964
• Harold Scott, 1960-1962
• Rudolph Nemser, 1954-1960
• Hvezdon Kafka, 1950-1954
• Arthur H. Tripp, 1946-1950
• James W. MacDonald, 1943-1946
• Roscoe E. Trueblood, 1930-1943
• John Mills Wilson, 1924-1929
• George Kent, 1920-1924
• Harvey C. Merrill, 1916-1920
• Charles S. Bodwell, 1913-1915
• George Tudor Jones, 1910-1913
• Joseph P. Sheafe, 1895-1910
• Benjamin Asbury Goodridge, 1892-1895
• Ai Stillman Annis, 1887-1892
• William Henry Reeby, 1885-1887
• Edward B. Maglathlin, 1882-1885
• Alfred Edgar Mullet, 1880-1882
• Daniel Francis Goddard, 1870-1880
• Jefferson Myers Fox, 1867-1869
• Henry Harvey Barber, 1861-1866
• William Augustus Whitwell, 1857-1861
• William Gustavus Babcock, 1855-1856
• Washington Gilbert, 1831-1855
• Ira Henry Thomas Blanchard, 1823-1831
• Warren Fay, 1814-1820
• Stephen Bemis, 1801-1814
• William Emerson, 1792-1799
• Ebeneezer Grosvenor, 1782-1788
• Daniel Johnson, 1769-1777
• Joseph Wheeler, 1759-1768
• John Secomb, 1733-1757